What Writing Your Novel and Dog Training Have in Common

When I’m not writing, a good chunk of time is spent training our dogs, two Pembroke Welsh Corgis. They are (most of the time) good little pups, who compete in American Kennel Club sanctioned Obedience and Rally trials. Writing and dog training are more connected than I first thought and there are five principles that apply to both.

Sit – Stay

A dog must learn to sit and stay on command, no matter what distractions lurk in the background. A writer, any writer, must also learn to sit and stay, ignoring the distractions of twitter, Facebook, or whatever prevents words from going onto that blank page. Drafting, writing and revising a novel length manuscript take patience and the learned skill of sit – stay (at the keyboard).


A Tight Leash is Never Good

When you’re handling a dog in an Obedience exercise, or through a Rally course, a tight leash will get you disqualified. If you have to literally drag your dog through the course, the dog gets frustrated, you get pissed and bad things happen. The tight leash means you haven’t trained enough to trust the dog to do the right thing and your dog doesn’t trust you enough to “lead” them. A writer can’t produce a novel manuscript if they are “holding on too tight.” If the writer is afraid to make a mistake, too concerned about word count and rigid in their adherence to an outline, they too will be disqualified by their readers. Compare your writing when you’re tense and stressed, versus when you let yourself go, outline be damned and let the characters run on a loose leash.

image courtesy of alop.org

image courtesy of alop.org

You Don’t Get a Dog Cookie Every Time

In our dog training, we’ve found that if your dog expects a treat, or a cookie every time you ask for a given behavior, they won’t be able to perform without them. Since you can’t use cookies, toys or treats in the Obedience or Rally rings, you end up with a dog that practices well but can’t deliver the goods without constant reinforcement. A writer has to learn to keep pounding out all the words without any positive reinforcement. If you wait to hear something positive, supportive or uplifting to encourage your writing, you’re gonna die. Rejections are plentiful in the writer’s world, so learn to perform without the nice scratch behind the ear, or pat on the head. When someone actually buys your book, writes a review, or tells you they liked your work, it means even more, because you weren’t expecting that cookie.

image courtesy of the cuteproject.com

image courtesy of the cuteproject.com

Go in Circles

In the Rally ring you and your dog have to negotiate tight turns, change pace and direction on a dime without tripping. These skills equally apply to drafting a novel. Whether you outline, or draft in a blinding stream of consciousness, the writer must be able to shift direction nimbly, weave through a complex maze of plot twists and clues to guide the reader through your story without falling flat on your face.


You Get Out What You Put In

With regular practice, discipline and patience, you and your dog can learn to perform when needed. You know the skills, your dog is familiar with them and when it’s time to perform, there is little doubt of the outcome. As a writer, it is easy to get complacent, lazy or frustrated. With continued practice, you expect more from yourself and you don’t settle for less. You’ve put in the work, you’ve set your expectations, the outcome of that novel manuscript will reflect what you’ve put into the process.


Good Dog! Good Writer!



  1. Love, love, love this post! The animal lover in me (and the struggling writer) can relate to this so much. Must take a remedial class in Sit-Stay (and get by on less dog cookies). Thanks for making me smile and reminding me of what I need to do. Tail wag of appreciation coming your way 🙂

    1. Thanks Diane! Another benefit of writing with dogs (sounds like it could be my Indian name) is that when I get too wound up and stressed on what I’m trying to write, I look at those little doggy faces and everything’s okay. Thanks again and woof!

  2. I’m being trained by four cats. They sometimes have to be tricked into doing the right thing. The only way to achieve the annual visit to the vet for shots is to throw their favorite feather wand with dangling jingle balls into the cat carrier before they will enter it. Sometimes the only way to get this writer into the office is to leave the white chocolate chips in a jar by the computer. Rewards work if you give them to yourself.

    1. I love the visual of a feather wand dangling over a keyboard when the jar of chocolate chips runs dry. Keyboard cats are great mascots because they never get stressed out over deadlines or plot holes.

  3. Yep, I get this! Certainly no cookies or positive reinforcement during the process – although I will treat myself to good coffee and the occasional choccy biscuit!

    1. An occasional treat keeps a writer sane. Especially chocolate and coffee!

  4. Excellent post – one of the best I’ve ever read about writing. I particularly like the section about reviews. Best not to expect them but to be thrilled when you get them!

    1. Thanks for the very kind comment! And, yes the dogs teach me about writing and just a about everything else in my life.

  5. […] adorable, this post on what writing and dog training have in common made me laugh. A huge thank you to James […]

    1. Thanks, Sue. Training these little guys keep me semi-sane.

      1. Love your blog. I’m hooked!

      2. Thank you Sue, I really appreciate your support!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: